Frequently Asked Questions
What should I do if a product I own is listed as "HIGH"?
First, if the product is a safety device like a car seat, we strongly advise you to continue using the product. Car seats save lives and should be used to transport children in vehicles. In general vacuuming the product and area with a HEPA filter can help because chemicals end up getting attached to dust molecules and that is one route of exposure (ingestion/dermal contact with dust). There have been studies that indicate washing hands also limits exposure (because of hand to mouth contact).
Are the chemicals tested for in HealthyStuff.org the
only chemicals of concern in consumer products?
No. The rapid screening technology used for HealthyStuff.org
can identify the presence and concentration of some chemicals of concern.
Consumer products may contain other hazardous materials that
this technology is not designed to identify. Other chemicals
of concern in consumer products include Bisphenol A and phthalates,
which cannot be detected by the XRF machine. HealthyStuff.org is a first
step in providing information to consumers on some chemicals of concern
in the everyday products we purchase.
What should I do if I already own a product that has
a high level of lead in it?
HealthyStuff.org recommends that you remove the product
from your home, unless the item is a safety device like a car seat.
Should my child or pet be tested for lead if he or
she has played with a toy or other product that was found to contain
high levels of lead?
Parents should consult with their pediatrician or veterinarian
to determine whether a lead test for their child or pet is warranted.
The detection of lead in a product does not necessarily mean
there has been exposure. It is important to remember that toys, childcare articles
and pet products are just one source of lead exposure for kids and pets.
Children and pets are exposed to lead from other sources as well. For
tips on reducing lead exposure for children and pregnant women, visit: http://www.cdc.gov/nceh/lead/tips.htm. or
the American Academy of
Pediatrics, Toy Safety Resource. For tips on reducing and managing lead exposure in pets, visit: American Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals.
Is lead paint still the most important source of lead exposure for children?
Yes. Generally, the largest risk of lead exposure for children comes
from lead paint in older homes. Please consult the Centers for Disease
Control website for tips on reducing lead exposure for children and pregnant
women, visit: http://www.cdc.gov/nceh/lead/tips.htm.
However, the risk from lead and other hazardous chemicals
in products is real. In particular, metal jewelry with high levels of
lead or cadmium, if swallowed by a child, can be very hazardous. The
contribution of products to the overall level of hazardous chemicals
in children is not known, and will vary depending on the child's behavior
and the products to which they are exposed. HealthyStuff.org believes
these exposures are completely avoidable and therefore unnecessary, and
product manufacturers should remove hazardous chemicals from consumer
How can consumers choose safer products?
HealthyStuff.org offers tips to help consumers choose
safer products. Please see our Consumer
Resources page. It is also important
to check products at home against government recall lists (see below).
However, the only way to assure safer products for everyone is for the
government to properly regulate chemicals in products. It cannot be the
responsibility of consumers alone to determine which products are safe.
Citizen pressure is essential to make the government and manufacturers
bring safer products to market. Please refer to the Take
Action link on
this site for information on ways to add your voice to those calling
How do I find out about product recalls?
For information on all product recalls, see the Consumer
Product Safety Commission at: http://www.cpsc.gov/en/Recalls//.
If you suspect that a product is unsafe, or to report an unsafe product,
contact the CPSC on the internet, or by phone: http://www.cpsc.gov/en/About-CPSC/Contact-Information/
or 1-800-636-CPSC. To receive email recall alerts from Consumer Product
Safety Commission, visit http://www.cpsc.gov/cpsclist.aspx.
Why focus on PVC?
From production to disposal, PVC is associated with the use and release
of hazardous chemicals.
During the production phase, workers at PVC facilities, as well as residents
in surrounding areas, may be exposed to vinyl chloride (the building block
of PVC) and/or dioxin (an unwanted byproduct of PVC production), both
of which are carcinogens. At the end of a product's life, PVC can create
dioxin when burned. PVC is not easily recycled.
Lead and other metals are sometimes used as a stabilizer or to impart
other properties to PVC plastic.
Because PVC is an inherently brittle material, it requires additives
to make it flexible, long-lasting, or to impart other properties. While,
HealthyStuff's XRF technology cannot detect many of these additives,
but they can potentially have adverse impacts on human health
are phthalates a concern?
Phthalates can harm reproductive development, especially
in boys. They have also been linked to asthma. Since February 2009,
childcare products (products for children under three years of age) and
toys (toys produced for children under twelve years of age) containing
concentrations of DEHP, BBP, and DBP (three different types of phthalates)
greater than 0.1% have been considered banned hazardous materials. Three
additional phthalates, DINP, DnOP, and DIDP in concentrations greater
than 0.1% have been placed on a provisional ban and are being re-evaluated
for their safety (CPSIA 2008). HealthyStuff's XRF technology cannot detect
phthalates, but their presence has been confirmed in the past in consumer
products with the use of other laboratory technology.
Why is lead a concern?
Lead can harm brain development, with effects including
reduced IQ, shorter attention span, and delayed learning. There is no
safe level of lead exposure. Since August 2009, products containing
a concentration of lead—both
in the paint and in the product itself—greater than 300 ppm have
been listed as banned hazardous substances. This limit will belowered
to 100 ppm as of August 2011. The CPSC has the right to decrease the
amount of allowable lead as it sees fit and in accordance with technology
at the time (Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act, CPSIA 2008). According
to the CPSIA, electronic toys in the United States are exempt from the
lead ban, though this is subject to change by the CPSC as technology
improves (CPSIA 2008). Read more.
Why is cadmium a concern?
Cadmium is a known human carcinogen, and can harm the kidneys and lungs.
It can have adverse effects on motor skills and behavior.
What else can I do to protect my family?
Call the manufacturer and ask them to reformulate their
products to eliminate chemicals of concern, disclose the ingredients
in their products, and sign on
to reform principles. The most important single action you can take is
strong government policies because this is the only way to truly solve the
problem. Also, visit About Us to see if state level work is happening where you live.
Are newer products safer than older products?
In general, HealthyStuff.org has only tested products
manufactured from 2006-2009 and cannot make definitive conclusions
on older products. However, there is some concern that older products
may pose additional hazards. For instance, many older toys - those made
before regulations enacted on home paint in 1978- were coated with
lead paint. HealthyStuff.org has also tested a limited number of 1990-2004
vehicles and, on average, they have slightly higher levels of chemicals
than 2006-2010 model year vehicles. Still our researchers found a surprising
number of toys and other products purchased in 2008 and 2009 that contain
lead as well as other chemicals and far too many car, car seats and pet
products still contain elevated levels of hazardous chemicals.
Are less expensive products more likely than name-brand
products to contain toxic chemicals?
Chemicals of concern have been found in all types
of products from all types of stores. Even name-brand and high-end products
have been found to contain lead and other hazards.
Are products made in the USA safer than those made
in other countries?
HealthyStuff.org has not found a consistent correlation between the country of manufacture and the presence of toxic chemicals in products. A lot of our consumer products are produced outside
of the U.S. For example, eighty percent of all toys purchased in the
U.S. are made in China. Therefore, the majority of toys that we've previously
tested were from China. HealthyStuff.org has not found a consistent correlation
between the country of manufacture and the presence of toxic chemicals
in toys. Twenty-one percent of toys from China and 16% of those from
all other countries had detectable levels of lead in 2008. In 2008, 17
toys manufactured in the U.S. were sampled and 35% of those had detectable
levels of lead. Seven toys (2%) had levels above 600 ppm. One of the
highest lead levels detected (190,943 ppm) was on a Halloween Pumpkin
Pin made in the USA. In addition, our tests of vehicles and car seats
produced in the U.S. consistently show elevated levels of one or more
hazardous chemicals. These levels of hazardous chemicals in US manufactured
products are comparable to similar products produced in Asia or Europe.
Can I test products for lead by myself?
Lead-testing kits are widely available, but consumers
should be aware that they can provide both false positives and false
negatives. Kits may provide a screening tool, but should not be used
as an absolute determination of safety. Consumer Reports has rated
home lead testing kits. For their recommendations, see: http://blogs.consumerreports.org/safety/2007/10/testing-the-lea.html.
The CPSC also recently tested lead testing kits. For their recommendations,
More accurate results can be provided by a testing organization with an XRF analyzer
or through a laboratory testing (which is expensive). Some local health
departments have an XRF that can test toys.
IMPORTANT NOTE: HealthyStuff.org ratings do not provide a measure of health risk or chemical exposure associated with any individual product, or any individual element or related chemical. Follow this link to read more.